Monday, July 18, 2011

Where is the accountability in Indian Governance

Here are the budget details downloaded from http://indiabudget.nic.in/glance.asp.   A number of observations can be drawn from this data.  This is just a sample...

  • Ministry of Rural Development tops with 15% of the overall budget. According to latest census data, India has 593,731 inhabited villages.  This budget translates to 14.78 Lac Rupees per village per year
  • 5 Ministries (Human Resources Development, Petroleum and Natural Gas, Power, Rural Development and Railways) each have over 50 thousand crore Rupees (~USD 1.2 Billion) in budget and account for 57% of the overall budget.  How transparently are these departments managed?
  • Ministry of Women and Child Development gets 12,650 Crore Rupees.  Has the standard of this segment of population dramatically improved?

I hope someone can point me to audits and quantifiable impacts for each department.

(In crore of Rupees)

2009-2010
2010-2011
2010-2011
2011-2012

Actuals
Budget
Revised
Budget


Estimates
Estimates
Estimates
Central Plan Outlay by Ministries/Departments





Ministry of Rural Development
74309
89340
89578
87800
Ministry of Petroleum and  Natural Gas
67306
69495
70088
74852
Ministry of Power
39678
60751
45668
66383
Railways
38867
40549
40218
56589
Ministry of Human Resource Development
29640
42036
43836
52060
Ministry of  Road Transport  and Highways
14933
25455
26210
27500
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
17647
22300
21518
26760
Ministry of Communications and Information Technology
16669
21862
16216
24300
Ministry of Steel
13323
17200
16159
21103
Ministry of Agriculture
9405
11880
14049
13662
Ministry of Women and Child  Development
8482
11000
10370
12650
Department of Atomic Energy
6527
8226
7628
10012
Ministry of Home Affairs
939
2001
2615
10000
Ministry of Finance
1120
2418
9997
9895
Ministry of Coal
5303
13518
8388
9303
Ministry of Civil Aviation
11148
9588
6731
9071
Ministry of Urban Development
7627
7606
8519
8054
Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation
4555
9422
7391
7955
Ministry of Shipping
2606
6494
6676
6525
Department of Space
3169
5000
4000
5700
Ministry of Science and Technology
3829
4825
4817
5679
Ministry of Social Justice  and Empowerment
2449
4500
4300
5375
Ministry of Textiles
4222
4725
4725
5000
Ministry of Chemicals and  Fertilisers
1216
3480
3284
4525
Ministry of Commerce and Industry
2289
2730
2730
3300
Ministry of Micro, Small  and Medium Enterprises
1571
2550
2725
3250
Ministry of Minority Affairs
1709
2600
2500
2850
Ministry of Environment and Forests
1630
2200
2200
2300
Ministry of New and  Renewable Energy
1760
1950
2492
2150
Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises
2339
2965
2906
2136
Ministry of Planning
86
2000
1045
1600
Ministry of Mines
948
1763
1129
1589
Ministry of Tribal Affairs
616
1200
1234
1430
Ministry of Labour and Employment
792
1000
1227
1300
Ministry of Earth Sciences
754
1000
950
1220
Ministry of Tourism
935
1050
1000
1111
Ministry of Law and Justice
255
280
280
1000
Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports
2935
2844
2384
1000
Ministry of Information  and Broadcasting
473
850
850
861
Ministry of External Affairs
718
700
825
800
Ministry of Culture
573
735
735
785
Ministry of Water Resources
492
700
560
720
Ministry of Food Processing Industries
273
400
400
600
Ministry of Statistics and  Programme Implementation
85
268
123
600
Ministry of Consumer Affairs,  Food and Public Distribution
257
428
364
423
Ministry of Personnel, Public  Grievances and Pensions
233
250
215
260
Ministry of Panchayati Raj
106
120
120
200
Ministry of Development of  North Eastern Region
81
190
188
191
Ministry of Corporate Affairs
33
40
87
28
GRAND TOTAL
406912
524484
502250
592457